The McStay Family Murders - Part One | #439

5 March 2026 · 1h 17m

RedHanded

Play — keeps going as you browse

Not rated yet

Comments

oldest first

Show notes

How does a family completely vanish? That was the question that plagued investigators after Michael McStay reported his brother Joe McStay missing on the 15th of February 2010, along with Joe’s wife Summer, and their two children, Joe Jr and Gianni.

It took four years to discover the fate of the McStay family: a fate that cast a lens across their entire lives. Everyone from Joe’s business associates Chase Merrit and Dan Kavanaugh, to Joe’s own brother Michael, had something to gain from the family’s disappearance – but who had the mentality to kill them for it?

Patreon - Ad-free & Bonus Episodes

YouTube - Full-length Video Episodes

TikTok / Instagram

Sources and more available on redhandedpodcast.com

More episodes

ShortHand: The Bling Ring28 Jul ShortHand: Lili’uokalani - The Last Queen of Hawai’i24 Jul The Golden State Killer - Part 1: A Horror Beyond Belief | #46023 Jul ShortHand: Alcatraz – Escape from Devil's Island21 Jul FROM THE VAULT - Richard Chase: The Vampire of Sacramento - Parts 1&220 Jul

Where to listen

Where to listen to RedHanded

Listen on Apple Podcasts