On the morning of April 10, 1936, Nancy Evans Titterton, novelist and wife of NBC Radio executive Lewis Titterton, was found sexually assaulted and strangled to death in the bathtub of her apartment in Beekman Place, a prominent New York City apartment building. Upon first inspection, the crime scene yielded few clues—a fingerprint in the bathroom, a length of rope used to bind her hands, and little else.
Within a week, detectives were no closer to solving the case than they were on day one, until a break finally came when the rope and a single horsehair was traced to a local upholstery shop, and ultimately to an apprentice upholsterer named John Fiorenza, who, along with his boss, Theodore Kruger, discovered Nancy’s body while delivering a piece of furniture.
Eventually, Fiorenza confessed to assaulting and murdering Nancy Titterton, but claimed temporary insanity. At the trial, the jury rejected Fiorenza’s defense and he was found guilty and he was executed in January 1938. Although the case of Nancy Evans Titterton may seem rather straightforward, it stands as an early example of science and law enforcement coming together to solve a case that had previously seemed destined to remain unsolved.
Thank you to the Incredible Dave White of Bring Me the Axe Podcast for research and Writing support!
References
New York Times. 1937. "Clemency is asked for John Fiorenza." New York Times, January 12: 3.
—. 1936. "Fiorenza counsel accuses a 'fiend'." New York Times, May 21: 7.
—. 1936. "Fiorenza doomed to electric chair." New York Times, June 6: 34.
—. 1936. "Fiorenza insane, alienst swears." New York Times, May 26: 48.
—. 1936. "Fiorenza's mother sets up an alibi." New York Times, May 23: 34.
—. 1936. "Plea of insanity by Fiorenza likely." New York Times, April 23: 5.
—. 1936. "Scientists study clues to slayer of Mrs. Titterton." New York Times, April 12: 1.
—. 1937. "Titterton slayer is put to death." New York Times, January 22: 42.
—. 1936. "Upholdwerter's aide confesses murder of Mrs. Titterton." New York Times, April 22: 1.
—. 1936. "Woman writer, 34, found strangled in bathtub in home." New York Times, April 11: 1.
Schechter, Harold. 2014. The Mad Sculptor: The Maniac, the Model, and the Murder that Shook the Nation. New York, NY: Little A Publishing .
Times Union. 1936. "Countess tells of prowler knocking on door 8 hours before writer was strangled." Brooklyn Times Union, April 11: 1.
—. 1936. "Arraigned and denied bail, he then retraces flght." Times Union (Brooklyn, New York), April 22: 1.
—. 1936. "Fiorenza guilty in first degree." Times Union (Brooklyn, New York), May 28: 1.
—. 1936. "Johnnie was a good boy, sobs mother of slayer." Times Union (Brooklyn, New York), April 21: 1.
—. 1936. "Hunt mysterious prowler." Times Union (Brooklyn, NY), April 12: 1.
Cowritten by Alaina Urquhart, Ash Kelley & Dave White (Since 10/2022)
Produced & Edited by Mikie Sirois (Since 2023)
Research by Dave White (Since 10/2022), Alaina Urquhart & Ash Kelley
Listener Correspondence & Collaboration by Debra Lally
Listener Tale Video Edited by Aidan McElman (Since 6/2025)
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.